Beer Review: A Case of Fool Circle
You read that right - a freakin’ case bitches! Nice having a birthday and a kick-ass brother who is a homebrewer. Least I can do is tell you about them.
For my birthday I received a case of Fool Circle home brew beers. 6 types, 4 of each. In the case were the following:
- IPA
- Saison
- American Brown Ale - the ABA Grand Experiment
- Peach ABA
- Amarillo Amber
- Helmut - the “Small Beer”
Go and check out Brian’s notes and comments about all of them….
OK!! you’re back! Since there are 6, these will be briefer.
IPA
The IPA was a golden amber that had the sweet, sticky hop smell that I look for. This was not a monster IPA as far as Alc% is concerned but the hop profile was aromatic and big. I like my hoppy beers to introduce themselves, get to know me, kick off their shoes. This one did just that. It was well balanced considering the amount of hops. It had the great hop “sticky” factor. That would not make sense unless you have had it. It was nice and enjoyable.
Saison
I like farmhouse ales, and this did not disappoint. I was good, but I did find the sweet to spice ratio a bit off for my taste. Perhaps it was the time since it was brewed and the flavor profile changing. It was a slower drinker for me. It warmed on the way down.
American Brown Ale - the ABA Grand Experiment
This was a project to brew to recipe and create a Brown Ale in the ABA style. It was a fine brew and very very drinkable. I like brown ales, a type that seems to be forgotten or too often compared to porters. It is not a porter. This brew was pleasant to the palate and went down very smooth. I could have a few of these. This brew has won some awards and you can tell. Of course, for the competitions, with their effort to brew to style, and Bri and Garrett’s specific work and skills, I am not surprised it has faired well.
Peach ABA
This is more of “mad scientist” brew for Brian. The idea should work and create a pleasant sweet result. Well, overall I think the brew (or what you got of it) was nice, especially the finish. I think the peach sweet came through at the end of the taste and lingered nicely on the tongue. I did have 2 out of 4 bottle of this gush when opened. Brian discusses this on his site.
believe this beer (the PABA) was ‘digged’ hard because it was a ‘gusher’. I have a theory on why the PABA has become a gusher of a beer: I feel as if I should have moved the beer to a tertiary fermenter to let the peaches completely fall clear since I peached the ABA during secondary thus voiding the potential for the effects of the secondary fermenter, and because the beer had not fallen mostly clear a significant amount of sediment was carried over to the bottles, thus giving increased nucleation sights for the carbonation to escape suspension in the beer, leading to a gusher. I feel as if this beer did not have off flavors, was not infected, and was thoroughly tested by drinking 18 of them in one night, thank you Erik & Robert.
I think it had a nice complex flavor. It seemed to taste more chocolaty than the ABA. Perhaps the peach sugars enhanced the malt profile. It reminded me of the brown ale answer to Magic Hat’s #9.
Amarillo Amber
This was my wife’s favorite,drinking 3 out of 4 of them. I thought this was well balanced and “clean” for lack of a better term. Catherine thought they were delicious and “helped” finish them rather efficiently.
Helmut - “Small Beer”
The small beer was a bastard child of his Imperial Stout brew - named Vader; thus the Helmut naming convention. I really like this brew. I mentioned to Brian that this reminded me of a “fat mild”. I like session brews and this gave the impression of that from its mouth feel and taste, though it was a tad more potent (Brian and confirm that - it may not be). It made me long for a nice “table mild” to roll through an evening and drink a whole bunch of them on cold winter night shooting the shit with friends.
There you have it! 6 FC brews - one case! I know - you are jealous.
Thanks Brian - I am happy to help get rid of extra inventory any time!


Brian
December 5th, 2007Glas you enjoyed your mixed case, just like in PA!
The IPA is definitely a sticky-icky IPA, I just wish the carbonation level would come up higher, how was the carbonation on yours?
I feel you a little bit on the Saison about the sweet/spice mix, but in all honesty when I gave them to you they had really just hit their peak. I had drunk a case and half that weren’t even as good as the one you had. Very long time to mature, very long time to carbonate.
The ABA is the bomb! I will definitely be making that one again in ‘08.
That’s funny you sould say that about #9 in regards to the PABA because that is what I wanted. I didn’t want to do apricot or artificial fruit flavor (which is what #9 is), but I did whant that lovely combo that #9 has. I was thinking ‘fresh peaches and chocolate ice cream’ or something along those lines.
The Amarillo Amber was touch-n-go for me. I drank it sometimes and it was great, I drank it sometimes and it was mellow, and I drank it sometimes and it was cheesy. Very odd beer for me.
Oh, Helmut, that little bastard. It actually is quite weak being only 3.25% alc. For me, I can tell that it is a second runnings beer, very astringent to me like over-steeped tea, but like over-steeped tea still quite flavorful. I wouldn’t be against a repeat attempt of doing a second-runnings beer, but I would do a couple things a little differently to help give it a better life.
Thanks for the reviews. Up next: ‘07 Hard Cider, Imperial Stout, Tripel, Dubbel!
David http://www.zogworld.com
December 6th, 2007It was low. Not much head to speak of.
I totally get the saison maturation factor. I believe this could become a very good brew. It happens to be one of my favorite styles so I will happily try another down the line
And I want to try Vader!
Brian
December 6th, 2007Oh yeah, and ingredients lined-up to make a Honey Oatmeal Stout (yeah right!), a Belgian Abbey Ale (Belgian Red?), and a Rye IPA or RYPA. Maybe we could brew that stout in time to drink it before this summer, is that a wide enough window for you
David http://www.zogworld.com
December 6th, 2007Honey Oatmeal Stout (yeah right!)?? HMMMM - That sounds like a good idea! Call it Uncle Tupelo’s . That would work!